We are open May 6th - October 8th 2022. Please book directly with us via our website! We look forward to welcoming you at our beautiful place on Cape Cod.
Cape Cod and Martha's Vineyard are two premium New England getaways, each offering distinct experiences for travelers. Cape Cod is accessible year-round by car, featuring a mix of lively tourist hubs and serene coastal escapes. Martha's Vineyard, accessible only by ferry or air, offers a more secluded island vibe with striking seasonal contrasts. Here's what sets them apart:
Bottom Line: Choose Cape Cod for accessibility, variety, and year-round appeal. Opt for Martha's Vineyard if you prefer exclusivity, island charm, and seasonal vibrancy.
Cape Cod and Martha's Vineyard each have their own take on luxury, shaped by their unique personalities. While Cape Cod leans into its intimate coastal charm, Martha's Vineyard offers a more polished, exclusive island experience. Both destinations cater to travelers seeking upscale comforts, but they do so in ways that reflect their distinctive vibes.
Cape Cod's luxury scene is all about boutique inns and historic properties, where smaller, intimate settings meet the classic character of New England. These accommodations focus on personalized service and a warm, homey atmosphere.
Take A Little Inn on Pleasant Bay, for example. With its cozy, modern design featuring neutral tones and pops of color, it embodies the "coastal grandmother" aesthetic. This charming inn offers nine uniquely decorated rooms, a European-inspired breakfast, private dock access for kayaking and sailing, and easy access to nearby quaint towns [5].
For a more expansive experience, Chatham Bars Inn sets the standard for full-service luxury in the region. This historic property boasts an eight-acre private farm, a high-end spa, an elegant pool area, and exclusive beachfront access. It’s a destination in itself, blending history with top-tier amenities [5].
Other properties, like Frederick William House, enhance the guest experience with thoughtful extras such as complimentary bicycles and personalized local tips to help you explore Cape Cod like a local [7].
Martha's Vineyard offers a different flavor of luxury, focusing on exclusivity and modern sophistication. Here, the accommodations are designed to provide a more private and polished experience.
The Harbor View Hotel is a standout, offering five-star service with stunning views of Edgartown Harbor. This property combines the charm of a grand historic building with modern accommodations, including private Captain's Cottages. It’s an ideal choice for those seeking a mix of tradition and contemporary comfort [4].
For a unique blend of laid-back Vineyard vibes and international flair, The Christopher Hotel delivers. Marketed as "Where the Vineyard Meets St. Barts", this boutique property creates a chic yet relaxed atmosphere that’s perfect for a getaway [3].
Boutique options like The Nobnocket Boutique Inn focus on intimate luxury, offering locally sourced gourmet breakfasts tailored to individual preferences and inviting communal spaces designed for relaxation and connection [6][8].
If you're looking for variety, Faraway Martha's Vineyard features six distinct lodging options, including the Mizzentop House suites. These suites come with thoughtful amenities like kitchenettes, dining areas, spacious living rooms, and dressing areas with vanities. Guests also enjoy access to private pools, fitness courtyards, cruiser bikes, and in-room perks like stocked minibars and washers and dryers [9].
Cape Cod charms with its cozy, authentic New England vibe, while Martha's Vineyard impresses with its sophisticated, exclusive atmosphere. Whether you prefer the quaint intimacy of Cape Cod or the refined elegance of Martha's Vineyard, both destinations promise unforgettable stays. Up next: a closer look at dining and local attractions.
Cape Cod and Martha's Vineyard each bring something special to the table when it comes to luxury dining. Cape Cod leans into its rich maritime history with classic seafood dishes, while Martha's Vineyard takes a farm-to-table approach, showcasing the island's agricultural abundance.
Cape Cod's culinary scene is a love letter to its coastal roots. Menus here are shaped by the day's fresh catch, with traditional New England recipes taking center stage. It's a place where Atlantic seafood meets time-honored preparation.
Twenty-Eight Atlantic, located at the Wequassett Resort, is a standout destination for fine dining. Under the guidance of Executive Chef James Hackney, it earned the distinction of being Cape Cod's first and only Forbes Five-Star restaurant. Guests can choose from two-course and four-course prix fixe menus or indulge in a seven-course tasting menu that highlights coastal flavors with a refined touch. The restaurant also boasts an award-winning wine list, making it a must-visit for a luxurious dining experience [14].
For those who crave waterfront dining, The Ocean House Restaurant is a top choice. Overlooking the Nantucket Sound, it has been recognized as one of OpenTable's 2023 Top 100 Most Scenic Restaurants. It also earned accolades in Cape Cod Time's 2023 Community Choice Awards for Fine Dining, Best Waterfront Restaurant, and Most Romantic Restaurant. The menu features elevated dishes like Wagyu slider dumplings, lobster tagliatelle, and fresh halibut, all crafted with local seafood and organic ingredients [15].
"Those looking for dinner with picturesque water views must make their way over to The Ocean House... The dining room overlooks the Nantucket Sound, making it one of the most wonderfully scenic restaurants on the Cape... The Ocean House brings true five-star luxury to the area, with an indulgent menu featuring items such as Wagyu slider dumplings, lobster tagliatelle pasta, and fresh halibut. The combination of the food and views make for a delectable and breathtaking experience." - Observer [15]
Another gem is Cuvée At Chatham Inn, which offers a daily-changing dégustation menu. Each dish reflects a modern, globally inspired take on local flavors, ensuring a fresh and exciting dining experience [18].
For a more relaxed yet refined setting, Pisces Coastal Kitchen delivers. Their menu emphasizes fresh, seasonal ingredients sourced from regional farms and coastal waters, creating an inviting atmosphere paired with exceptional food [16].
While Cape Cod celebrates its maritime legacy, Martha's Vineyard takes a different approach, weaving its agricultural heritage into every dish.
Martha's Vineyard has carved out a reputation for gourmet dining rooted in the island's farm-to-table philosophy. Here, chefs collaborate with local farmers and fishermen, crafting menus that shift with the seasons and daily harvests.
The Terrace at The Charlotte Inn sets the bar high for fine dining. As part of the prestigious Relais & Châteaux network, the restaurant blends classic cuisine with French accents and international influences, all while spotlighting locally sourced, seasonal ingredients [10].
State Road is another shining example of the island's commitment to fresh, local dining. With vegetables and herbs sourced daily from its on-site garden and nearby farms, the menu changes weekly to reflect the best seasonal offerings [11][13].
For those seeking refined contemporary American cuisine, Bettini Restaurant in Edgartown delivers. Known for its coastal chic ambiance, Bettini has earned a 4.7/5 rating on OpenTable from over 1,000 reviews and received the Wine Spectator Best of Award of Excellence in both 2022 and 2023. Signature dishes like lobster pasta carbonara and seared scallops pair beautifully with an exceptional wine program [12][17].
The farm-to-table ethos extends beyond restaurants. Morning Glory Farm, a family-run establishment since the 1970s, offers visitors a chance to enjoy seasonal produce, classic zucchini bread, and homemade pies in an authentic farm setting [11].
For a unique experience, The Grey Barn & Farm combines European-style cheesemaking with farm tours. Known for its artisan cheeses and small-batch sourdough breads, it captures the artisanal spirit of the island [11].
For something more contemporary, The Port Hunter in Edgartown delivers a lively vibe with creative cocktails and a menu featuring Vineyard oysters and lobster tacos. It's a perfect example of how farm-to-table dining can be casual yet sophisticated [11].
Even bakeries embrace the local philosophy. The Scottish Bakehouse, which maintains its own on-site farm, serves organic options like gluten-free dishes and sandwiches that highlight the island's flavors [11].
Cape Cod and Martha's Vineyard each offer dining experiences tailored to different tastes. Cape Cod celebrates its maritime heritage with classic seafood dishes, while Martha's Vineyard takes a creative farm-to-table approach, showcasing the best of land and sea. Both destinations promise unforgettable meals that reflect their unique identities.
Cape Cod and Martha's Vineyard each offer their own charm, blending coastal beauty with rich history. Cape Cod boasts sprawling shorelines and historic towns, while Martha's Vineyard enchants visitors with its close-knit island vibe and natural splendor.
With 559 miles of shoreline, Cape Cod is a haven for beach lovers and outdoor enthusiasts alike [20]. The Cape Cod National Seashore spans 40 miles, featuring untouched beaches, scenic woodlands, and hiking trails [20]. Popular spots like Coast Guard Beach in Eastham and Nauset Beach in Orleans offer quintessential Cape experiences. For calmer waters, Mayflower Beach in Dennis, Old Silver Beach in Falmouth, and Craigville Beach in Barnstable are ideal for relaxation [20]. Race Point Beach is a standout, known for its wide sands, breathtaking sunsets, and seal sightings. Visitors can also trek to the historic Race Point Lighthouse, a 45-minute walk through picturesque dunes [19][21]. Guests at A Little Inn on Pleasant Bay can enjoy direct access to kayaking and sailing from the inn's private dock, perfect for exploring the serene waters of Pleasant Bay.
History buffs will appreciate the Pilgrim Monument, a 252-foot granite tower honoring the Pilgrims' 1620 landing, alongside the Provincetown Museum [21][29]. Cape Cod is also home to nearly 100 museums, countless galleries, craft studios, and more than a dozen theaters [25]. Provincetown, recognized as the nation’s oldest continuous art colony [28], is a must-see with its vibrant Commercial Street, filled with unique shops, art galleries, cafes, and historic architecture [19]. The Heritage Museums & Gardens in Sandwich showcase vintage cars, American folk art, and beautifully maintained gardens [29], while the Sandwich Glass Museum highlights the area’s 19th-century glassmaking heritage [21].
For active visitors, the Cape Cod Rail Trail offers 25 miles of paved paths stretching from South Dennis to Wellfleet [21]. Nature lovers can explore the Atlantic White Cedar Swamp in Wellfleet or join whale watching tours departing from Provincetown to the Stellwagen Bank National Marine Sanctuary [23]. These activities provide a mix of history, art, and outdoor adventure, making Cape Cod a luxurious coastal getaway.
Martha's Vineyard, while smaller in size, offers a unique blend of natural beauty and rich traditions. With 124 miles of pristine coastline and 40% of its land protected, the island is a peaceful retreat [23]. The Aquinnah Cliffs, with their striking clay formations and the historic Gay Head Light, are a highlight [22]. The cliffs also serve as the backdrop for the annual Gay Head 10k, a race that pairs physical challenge with stunning views [24].
The island’s history comes alive at the Martha's Vineyard Camp Meeting Association (MVCMA), home to a collection of Victorian cottages [22]. Nearby, the Gingerbread Cottages in Oak Bluffs - designated a National Historic Landmark - feature brightly colored homes dating back to the mid-1800s [27]. Visitors can also explore the Aquinnah Cultural Center, which preserves the heritage of the Wampanoag people [26], or follow the African American Heritage Trail to learn about the island’s African American history [26]. The Martha's Vineyard Museum houses an impressive collection of 30,000 artifacts, including tools, paintings, and maritime relics [27].
For a touch of nostalgia, the Flying Horses Carousel in Oak Bluffs, one of the oldest operating carousels in the U.S., is a delightful stop [22]. The Edgartown Lighthouse offers another historic gem, perfect for photography and exploration [22].
Chappaquiddick Island, a short ferry ride from Edgartown, provides a quieter escape with serene beaches, hiking trails, and birdwatching opportunities [22][23]. The island’s preserved lands make it a haven for nature enthusiasts seeking tranquility.
Each destination offers its own blend of attractions, setting the stage for tailored, upscale experiences along these stunning coasts.
When planning a trip to Cape Cod or Martha's Vineyard, timing plays a big role in shaping your experience. These destinations shine in different ways throughout the year, offering everything from lively summer festivals to quiet off-season escapes, each with its own pricing and charm.
Cape Cod is a destination that welcomes visitors all year, with each season offering something special. In the summer months of July and August, the area comes alive with energy and activities [32]. During this peak season, hotel rates typically range between $580 and $1,500 per night [35].
Spring brings the vibrant Brewster in Bloom festival, complete with daffodils and parades. Summer offers highlights like the Hyannis Father's Day Car Show and Wellfleet Restaurant Week. Winter is all about cozy holiday experiences, such as the Falmouth Holidays by the Sea Weekend and the Chatham Christmas Stroll [31].
If you visit in September, you'll enjoy warm ocean waters and a calmer atmosphere. This shoulder season is perfect for kayaking or relaxing at private docks without the summer crowds.
Winter transforms Cape Cod into a peaceful retreat. Seasonal festivities include Santa arriving by boat, caroling at Nobska Lighthouse, and charming Christmas parades [31].
While Cape Cod offers something for every season, Martha's Vineyard stands out for its dramatic shift between a bustling summer and a tranquil off-season.
Martha's Vineyard thrives on its seasonal rhythm. In the summer, the island's population soars from 15,000 residents to nearly 100,000 visitors [34]. This creates a lively atmosphere filled with social events and premium pricing [33].
Notable summer events include the MV Agricultural Fair (August 21-24, $15 per adult) and Grand Illumination Night on August 20, featuring hundreds of lanterns and live music [30]. As the season shifts to fall, the island hosts the MV Striped Bass Derby, Tivoli Day block parties, and the Harvest Festival [30].
Winter on Martha's Vineyard offers a completely different experience. The island population drops to around 20,530 year-round residents [36]. Travel becomes more affordable, with Steamship Authority ferry tickets costing $10 each way and parking at $10 per day through March [37]. Luxury accommodations also become more accessible, with rates at places like Harbor View Hotel starting at $269 per night and Sea Crest Beach Hotel at $261 per night [38].
Holiday events in December include Christmas in Edgartown (December 11-14), Tis the Season in Tisbury, and Light Up Oak Bluffs, which features twinkling lights and festive activities [30][37].
Winter visitors can enjoy quieter perks, like walking scenic trails, sampling seasonal dishes, and visiting the Island Alpaca Farm [36]. Many hotels stay open year-round, offering cozy amenities like in-room massages, breakfast in bed, and private chef dinners [36][37].
Ultimately, the choice between Cape Cod and Martha's Vineyard depends on whether you prefer Cape Cod's steady year-round attractions or Martha's Vineyard's striking seasonal contrasts.
Here's a side-by-side look at what makes each destination stand out for luxury travelers.
This table outlines the key differences to help you decide which destination suits your preferences.
This comparison showcases the unique charm of each destination, making it easier to plan your luxury getaway.
Cape Cod offers iconic stays like the historic Chatham Bars Inn, which has been welcoming guests since 1914 with its Atlantic views and private beach. For a more modern touch, there's the Salt House Inn in Provincetown, known for its minimalist aesthetic and adults-only policy [1]. Over on Martha's Vineyard, you'll find boutique elegance at the Harbor View Hotel overlooking Edgartown Harbor or the Hob Knob, a 19th-century gem where every room has its own unique style [1].
When it comes to dining, Cape Cod has embraced sophisticated New American cuisine while staying true to its roots with Wellfleet oysters [40]. On Martha's Vineyard, farm-to-table dining reigns supreme, with standout spots like Bettini Restaurant (rated 4.6/5 on TripAdvisor) and Woods at Lambert's Cove Inn (rated 4.9/5 on OpenTable) [39][41].
Even the activities reflect each destination's character. Cape Cod offers accessible adventures like whale-watching tours priced between $50 and $70 per adult [43]. Martha's Vineyard, on the other hand, leans into exclusivity with private guided tours starting at $650 per group, alongside other premium options priced at $525 per group [22].
Whether you're drawn to Cape Cod's convenience or Martha's Vineyard's seasonal allure, each destination has something special to offer.
Your perfect luxury escape really comes down to your travel preferences. Both Cape Cod and Martha's Vineyard deliver unforgettable experiences, from top-notch accommodations to incredible dining and activities. But they cater to different types of travelers.
Cape Cod shines for those who value flexibility and variety. Its year-round accessibility and wide range of activities make it a favorite for families and groups with diverse interests. The convenience of bridges connecting it to the mainland means you can explore at your own pace. Plus, the lodging options are plentiful, from grand seaside resorts to charming boutique inns.
On the other hand, Martha's Vineyard is a haven for those craving exclusivity and calm. Limited access via ferry or air enhances its peaceful, tucked-away vibe. Travel expert Stephen Kota sums it up perfectly:
"Cape Cod is suited more for families looking for activities that fit all ages; Martha's Vineyard makes the best spot for a peaceful and serene vacation. Both offer beautiful views and entertaining activities to spend your vacation in the best possible way." [2]
Budget is another factor to consider. Martha's Vineyard tends to be pricier than Cape Cod, offering more intimate and exclusive experiences in return [2]. Timing your trip is also key. Cape Cod welcomes visitors year-round, while Martha's Vineyard has distinct seasonal highs and lows. For fewer crowds and pleasant weather, plan your visit in May, June, September, or October [2].
If Cape Cod is calling your name, A Little Inn on Pleasant Bay is a standout choice. This boutique property features nine uniquely styled rooms, private dock access, and proximity to picturesque towns like Chatham and Orleans. It perfectly captures the sophisticated yet relaxed luxury Cape Cod is known for.
When it comes to getting around, Cape Cod and Martha's Vineyard offer very different experiences. Cape Cod is best suited for travelers with a car. Its attractions and charming towns are spread out, making it perfect for road trips. However, if you're relying on public transportation, navigating the area can be a bit of a challenge.
Martha's Vineyard, in contrast, is much more compact and walkable, particularly in its main towns. Many visitors skip renting a car altogether, especially during the summer months when shuttle buses and ferries make getting around easy. That said, reaching the island itself requires some extra planning, as you'll need to take a ferry or book a flight - both of which can add time and cost to your trip.
Ultimately, your choice depends on how you prefer to travel. Cape Cod is ideal for those who enjoy the freedom of a car, while Martha's Vineyard suits those comfortable planning around ferry schedules or flights.
Cape Cod is renowned for its classic New England seafood favorites like fried clams, lobster rolls, and creamy clam chowder. Dining here feels like stepping into a maritime tradition, with many restaurants emphasizing fresh, locally-sourced ingredients that truly bring the coastal flavors to life.
Martha's Vineyard, while also celebrated for its seafood - think lobster, oysters, and clams - offers a broader culinary palette. The island is a treasure trove for food lovers, boasting artisanal baked goods, farm-to-table creations, and distinctive local specialties that cater to those craving variety and unique flavors.
While both destinations share a love for fresh, local ingredients, Cape Cod stays true to its seafood roots, whereas Martha's Vineyard delivers a more diverse and adventurous dining experience.
The best time to visit Cape Cod is late spring (May and June) or early fall (September and October). During these months, you’ll enjoy mild weather, fewer crowds, and plenty of opportunities to explore outdoor activities, attend charming seaside festivals, and take in the beautiful fall colors.
If Martha's Vineyard is on your list, summer (June through August) is the season for vibrant events, warm weather, and a lively island atmosphere. On the other hand, spring and fall offer a more peaceful vibe, pleasant temperatures, and fewer tourists - perfect for those looking to unwind in a quieter setting.
If you're looking for a peaceful and personal Cape Cod experience, now's the time to book your stay at A Little Inn on Pleasant Bay. With its quiet setting, friendly hosts, and small seasonal touches that make a big difference, it’s a great place to relax and enjoy the best bed and breakfast in Cape Cod. Whether you’re planning a weekend getaway or a longer break, don’t wait too long—anytime is the best time to visit, and rooms fill up fast.
